LBJ's Legacy: Unlikely President To Civil Rights Champion

LBJ

The flawed anti-hero behind the Civil Rights Act

PRESC Tutoring   ·   6-minute read

Interviewing candidates for teaching posts is always fraught with difficulties. One never knows how much of an act is being put on and what is genuine. One curveball question I ask without fail is: “You are throwing a dinner party for three people, either dead or alive. Who are you inviting, and why?” An instant rejection is anyone who mentions the dreaded trio of Gandhi, MLK and Nelson Mandela. While all three have historical merit, the banality of such an answer betrays unoriginal thought and has been the deciding factor in turning candidates down.

What should we be looking for? Firstly, originality—give an off-the-wall answer. Be original; be bold. In this vein of thinking, the next two blog posts will honour two men who wouldn’t naturally top anyone’s list of ‘favourite people’. However, that’s exactly why they are on mine. The flawed anti-hero is, for me, the most interesting topic of conversation. With that in mind, today will be in honour of Lyndon B. Johnson, the 36th President of the United States and the man most associated with escalating America’s war in Southeast Asia, particularly Vietnam. “Hey, hey, LBJ, how many kids did you kill today?” was a popular chant among anti-war protesters in the mid to late 1960s. Yet that is not going to be the mainstay of this post. It will get a mention, but this essay is here to argue that, without LBJ, there would have been no Civil Rights Act in 1964, which outlawed the segregation that had followed 99 years of pseudo-slavery and Jim Crow laws in the Southern states of America.

 

LBJ AT A GLANCE

Born                         1908, near Stonewall, Texas

1955–61                   Senate Majority Leader

1961–63                   Vice President under John F. Kennedy

1963–69                   36th President of the United States

1964–65                   Signs the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act

Died                         1973

 

“Hey, hey, LBJ, how many kids did you kill today?”

— Anti-war protest chant, 1960s

A Brief History Lesson

We need to start with a brief history lesson. The USA wrote its Constitution in 1787—a fine document, but one with some serious flaws, including the clause that counted an enslaved person as three-fifths of a free person. Even before independence in 1776, slavery was an accepted feature of American life. In 1861, the nation tore itself apart over this ‘original sin’ and saw 11 Southern states secede from the Union and wage a four-year Civil War, which cost roughly as many American lives as all of America’s other wars put together. In 1865, Abraham Lincoln and the Union won the war and, before he was assassinated by John Wilkes Booth, an actor and Confederate sympathiser, Lincoln pushed through Congress what became the 13th Amendment. In simple terms, this outlawed the practice of slavery. Soon, the 14th and 15th Amendments would be passed, which respectively gave equal protection under the law and, finally, the right to vote to Black men.

Now, this is where things get messy. During and after what is called ‘Reconstruction’, the Southern states didn’t take too kindly to these amendments being imposed on them by the ‘Yankee’ government in Washington, D.C. With the backing of the Supreme Court, the South was able to effectively get around these amendments and introduce what can be termed slavery by another name. The Jim Crow laws (named after a 19th-century minstrel-show character) saw the implementation of the infamous ‘separate but equal’ doctrine, which, in the eyes of the law, legalised segregation based on race. For those familiar with South Africa, it was essentially America’s apartheid. These laws lasted from circa 1883 to 1964.

The main reason these laws were able to persist for so long is the quirks of the U.S. Constitution. Allow me a paragraph to explain. While the USA is indeed one country made up of 50 states, these states are almost mini countries in themselves, where certain rules and regulations are not decided by Washington and the federal government but left to the states themselves. Issues such as education, healthcare, abortion and voting regulations are among those largely left for the states to decide. Added to this is the makeup of the U.S. political system. Every state, no matter how big or small, sends two senators to Washington. Wyoming, with a population of 584,000 people, and California, with 39 million people, have the same representation in the Senate. The Senate acts as the upper house in D.C., while the lower house is called the House of Representatives. This divvies up its members according to population: Wyoming sends one member to the House, while California sends 52. Together, both houses are called ‘Congress’ and make up 535 politicians, the legislative branch of the federal government. This is where the real power lies in America. It is a myth that the U.S. President is the most powerful man in the world. He (and I will say he, because so far only men have held the post) is constrained by what Congress allows him to do. In the modern era, Presidents such as Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and Joe Biden have seen many bills die on the floor of Congress due to partisan opposition from the Republicans.

The Accidental President

After 804 words, let’s get to why LBJ is about to get some good press. Firstly, Johnson should never have been President. He was Kennedy’s Vice President, a position described as ‘one heartbeat away from the presidency’ but more commonly derided by the line attributed to John Nance Garner as ‘not worth a bucket of warm piss’. Then the bullet from Lee Harvey Oswald’s gun on November 22, 1963, catapulted the man who had been born into poverty near Stonewall, in the hill country of Texas, into the White House. Johnson, who didn’t like JFK (and vice versa), had only been chosen as his running mate because he was a Southern Democrat and, in the makeup of American electoral politics, a very useful tool to help the liberal Catholic Kennedy from Massachusetts win the 1960 election.

Kennedy had wanted to pass Civil Rights legislation before his assassination. However, it is this author’s view that there was no way the electoral maths was ever going to be in his favour. The stalwarts of the Democratic Party in the South, such as Strom Thurmond and Richard Russell, who knew how to (and did) filibuster bills to death, were never going to give an idealistic liberal from New England the votes he needed to get the bill through the Senate. LBJ, however, was different. He was one of them—a dyed-in-the-wool Southerner who had been Senate Majority Leader from 1955 to 1961. He had personal and political relationships with the key decision-makers in the South. An unashamed bully, LBJ would stoop to any tactic to cajole and coerce fellow politicians into voting for what he wanted. Now, as President, with the aura of the White House on his side, he set out to fulfil Kennedy’s wish for Civil Rights legislation and add to his own ‘Great Society’ vision of America. One story (featured in the excellent film about his first year in office starring Bryan Cranston, ‘All the Way’) depicts Johnson on the toilet, quite openly defecating in front of an undecided senator to persuade him to vote in favour of the bill.

In Defence of Great Men

In some circles, it is uncouth and unpopular to reduce history to “Great Man Theory”. Some say it is reductionist and ignores the various PRESC factors that contribute to historical events. When it comes to the Civil Rights Act of 1964, I disagree wholeheartedly. Martin Luther King and Malcolm X are (rightly) considered important figures of the era. But the hard truth is that change in America is invariably political first and foremost, and the way the system works, with the Constitution, the amendment process and the separation of powers, means it takes a special person to navigate the built-in obstacles the Founding Fathers deliberately included.

The Verdict

Was Johnson flawed? Definitely. By all accounts, he could at times be downright crude, obnoxious and toxic. The Vietnam War took a huge toll on him and the nation. He chose not to seek re-election in 1968 and died a pariah five years later. But, as I stated earlier in the piece, that makes him even more interesting and, dare I say, is the reason he was able to negotiate the minefield that was the Southern Democratic Party in the 1960s.

Pre-2000s